Apr 13, 2009

Raaja Hindustani I

The movie "Raja Hindustani" was screened at the Archana theater in Coimbatore during my sophomore years.. 99% of the crowd watching that movie didn't understand one word of Hindi and yet the movie was running to packed houses. As far the College students who made the majority of those crowds were concerned, the Hindi handicap was momentarily forgotten in the charisma of Karishma! While this post is thankfully not about the on screen antics of Aamir khan on a rainy evening in that movie, it certainly drives home the point that - it takes something extra ordinary for the penetration of any North Indian art into the Tamil hinterland :-P ; It also offers a glaring contrast that often it needn't be as notorious as this case, For - the real 'Raaja Hindustani' of TN is the one with a double 'a' who has presented North Indian classical music as Trojans that conquered us.

This is a 3 part series in which I plan to (re)visit the application of Hindustani musical techniques, instruments and arrangements by Isaignani Ilaiyaraaja. Part 1 of this series will exclusively focus on pure creations of Raaja in this genre while in Part 2 I plan to take up Realizations of Hindustani genre based raagas and arrangements by Raaja. The last part of the series would focus on how he understood the original traditional concept and adopted it into a version of his own - be it in the deviation from tradition in the usage of exotic Hindustani classical Instruments or some radical experiments that no one else dared before.

In the context of South Indian film music, application of Hindustani style has not been unique to Raaja; Ghantasala Venkateswara Rao's delivery of the Raag 'Dharbari' (or Dharbari kaanada) in "Shiva Shankari" is probably still the benchmark of Hindustani singing that any South Indian singer might want to reach some day. And Composer Pendyala Nageswara Rao would be certainly proud of Ravindran Master for taking off from where he left and constructing a beautiful Sindhubhairavi in the Malayalam Sangeetham. The song 'Hari murali ravam' was not only a composer's delight, it also tested the boundaries of mighty KJ, who in the end of course proved why he is infallible. Speaking of testing the singer's ability, Hamsalekha came close to pinning down the South Indian Baadsha SPB in his "Umandu Gumandu". Winning the national award for that song was an achievement second only to SPB's own personal triumph that he actually accomplished the song as a proof to claim that he is the most versatile playback singer of our generation. (However I am not sure if its an original composition by Hamsalekha or simple reproduction of an established Hindustani number just like How ARR merely 'used' the track 'Bhor Bhaye' in Delhi 6); There have been traditional Qawwalis as well where our composers have shone bright with stars such as ARR ("Haji Ali", "Kwaja meri Kwaja", "Moula Moula - Delhi 6)" etc and Ravindran Master again (with "Tu Badi Maasha Allah") etc.,

Raaja's application of Hindustani music has not been as rigorously classical. But in terms of demonstration of the subject, individuality of the technique and the frequency with which his Wizardry was shown, he probably is second to none from the above list of composers. Raaja is more like the Neil Bhor who famously answered how a Barometer can be used in umpteen ways still relevant to Physics to measure the height of a building other than the one based on pressure which is the 'expected' answer.

In terms of usage of Tabla, Tabla tarang, Dholak and Pakhawaj though, He was certainly in the league of his own as you will see from the clips that follow. As yearly as 1978, he dared to experiment on a full blown scale in the song:
Manjolai Kilidhaano

India 24 Hours was a landmark album from Raaja in terms of showcasing his hindustani capabilities.
- First some experiment with
Tabla Tarang

- As far interweaving Tabla Bols so casually, I wonder if Raaja has any peer in south;
Tabla Bols
This track is a true case of tradition with ingenuity; In the second half of the track, the "Ae.. Aele lo" part is so unexpected and exhilarating.

- Now for some brief Khayal (in Bihag?) with some aid from Pakhwaj
Mini Khayal

- For some astute use of Pakhawaj together with Tabla, you can listen to this clip:
Pakhawaj

Back to film music and Singer Mano had this unexpected surprise in his noteworthy career - A Tarana in Raag Bihag set to Deep Chandi from the film:
Vanna Vanna Pokkaal

And bench mark composition of Raaja's Hindustani came through Pandit Ajoy Chakraborthy's Isaiyil Thodungudhamma; The song is set in a scale unique to Raaja whereby he uses Ga varja version of Kalyani;
Isayil Thodangudhamma
The intricate vocal work on this song is actually a norm in the Hindustani classical. So one can easily appreciate the richness and superior standards of this genre.

There are also few Jugal Bandhis hidden in Raaja songs; This one being my favorite
Sadha Sadha

I don't know whats it with Mano and Hindustani Singing; Obviously Mano was Raaja's favorite at some point as evident from some hard core Hindustani stuff showered on him. The premise of this song based on Raadha - Krishna type of setting must have spurred up Raaja that he came up with such an out and out wonder; I am tempted to tag this in the Raag Dharbari as well but for some "pure" Kanada prayogams; So probably its a mix of both.
Chithra doing a wonderful job initially (especially the oscillation of Melsthaai Ga - to Madhyasthaai Ri - and back to Melsthaai Ga during the pallavi ending is too good).
Gokulame Needhira
(if you listen carefully you can see how Raaja has instructed the singers to pronounce the swaras in the Hindustani way. For instance, Rishabam is pronounced in the Hindustani way; i.e., not like "Ri" with a "ee" sound but more like a "Ray" with an "ay" sound at the finish.)

and Mano left doing the catch up act here.
Gokulame Coda
Usage of Pakhwaj is noteworthy in this song as well.

The song "Ulagil Mudhal Isai Thamizh isaiye" by the master MSV is one of its kind for weaving parts of Carnatic and Hindustani in the same song and producing a genuine fusion. Raaja, being an open admirer of MSV thought himself not to be left behind and produced this wonder
Raagam Azhaithu Vandha
The uncanny knack of choosing both the scales that are Hindustani style based loose Raagas which are also equally popular in the Carnatic domain speaks for Raaja's astute taste. This way the separate portions look alluring whichever way you look at it (Desh for the carnatic part and Kaanada for the Hindustani part)

And in terms of providing light but authentic North Indian numbers, Raaja has proven himself time and again; The latest one being this gem of a song from Naan Kadavul:
Maa Ganga

The range of clips hosted in this post vary from 1978 to 2009; Think about it.. For a period of over 30 years he has fed us with such tasty dishes that we know doesn't belong here; And yet because of the way he "localized" them, we have taken it for granted as if these are wonders that are homegrown down south. Just like the ubiquitously available Tandoori Butter Naan or the Chole-Batura or the Paani Poori in every famous small town restaurants of TN.

With Love
Vicky

16 comments:

  1. That was a nice compilation vicky. Some more songs that come to my mind:

    1) There is a small hindustani piece in the song "unnai naan ariven" from Guna. It comes towards the end.

    2) In HeyRam again, there is this "pollatha" song which is not hindustani but a marathi folk song I guess. Again good use of Tabla and Pakhawaj I think. There is a western classical piece at the end of the song. Don't forget to listen to that. Wonder how he just fuses different styles.

    3) There is Tabla Bol in the "Kavithai Kelungal" song from Punnagai Mannan. Again fusion of different styles. Speaking of Kavithai Kelungal, here is my analysis of the song written some time back: http://rameshonmusic.blogspot.com/2005/12/kavithai-kelungal.html.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks Ramesh:
    1) Yes. The Guna piece would be a good fit here. I even have that bit clipped when I was preparing the other ones; but didn't add it since its a very 'Situational' piece. I was ruing that I should have added it to my Art of Composing blog post though.
    2) Yes. Thats more of folk than traditional Hindustani.
    3) Good Analysis on Kavidhai Kelungal to have captured what happens 'Actually' instead of using that as just a word to imply more :-) Great Job. Tabla Bols of first interlude is a type of "Padhant" (which is typical of dance numbers) just like the Vanna Vanna Pookal piece I quoted; So the emphasize is on dance oriented recital rather than the musically inclined rhythmic Tabla Bols of I24 hours I specified. In the 2nd interlude you have the carnatic Swara Jadhi based recital for the Bharata nattiyam part. Not sure if any one has managed two different dance school vocal renditions in the same song. Amazing experiment indeed.
    With Love
    Vicky

    ReplyDelete
  3. Dear vicky,
    Unga post ai padikum punniyam
    seidhu iruken.
    Thank to God.

    Jilla muzhuka nalla theiryum - Priyanka

    any idea about this song....

    With Love,
    Usha Sankar.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Vicky,

    it's a great post.

    it gives me very good path to pick up india 24 hours. what an amazing album.

    there is some more songs i would like to add with this.

    1.vaana mazhai pole puthu paadal
    2.oru kaaviyam arangerum neram
    3.naatham ezhunthathadi kannama

    i hope i understood the post correctly.
    Thanks and Regards
    Sridhar

    ReplyDelete
  5. @ Usha:
    Thank you very much for your sustained support.
    "Jilla Mulukka" has a good hidden classical feel thanks to both Gas and Both Nis (more like Kaapi Raaga), The usage of Tabla in that song is noteworthy.. but I am not sure if its in the Hindustani classical league of songs specified in this post.

    @ Sridhar:
    2 out of your list is already part of my next post in this series (But again please note they are Raaja's adoptions of HCM and not very classical songs); Naadham is more of Carnatic Sri Ranjani.. ITs Hindustani equivalent of Bageshir will find a place in my next post as well..

    With love
    Vicky

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi!! I found ur blog only now...its very interesting..keep posting

    ReplyDelete
  7. This is again an amazing analysis Mr.Vignesh!!!!
    Thank you so much!!!!
    How about the songs
    1. Azhagae from Raaja Paarvai
    2. Mangai nee maangani from Innisai Mazhai
    3. En ullil edho from rosapoo ravikaikarri

    ReplyDelete
  8. @ Latha Das:
    Thank you. Please note the songs you have mentioned are in the same category as also stated by Sridhar; i.e., they are not in the "original" or close to original genre but Raaja's adopted version of the HCM; All the songs mentioned by you are part of the next article in the series. So I am really glad that the readers are able to associate with HCM in a very positive way :-)
    With Love
    Vicky

    ReplyDelete
  9. Great article Vicky. India 24 hours is one heck of an album and now I get to know about all the hidden treasures in it through your post.

    Thanks.

    Rajkumar.C

    ReplyDelete
  10. @ Raj:
    Thanks..

    @ Vajra Krishna:
    Sure.. Thanks a lot for asking me to participate in your mission. I have noted the URL and will try to add some comments as and when I can..

    With Love
    Vicky

    ReplyDelete
  11. Dear Vicky,

    Excellent posts. You have demonstrated the true spirit of Ilaiyaraaja both the music analysis and your presentation. At once appealing to both the connoisseur and the layman.

    I really appreciate the pain you have taken to put together the samples as they really make a big difference in understanding your thoughts and also reliving the joy.

    Regards,
    Bhanu

    ReplyDelete
  12. They Hey Ram song 'Isayil Thodanguthammaa' is in fact Carnatic raga Hamsanadham, which is set to sound very Hindustani-ish in this excellent composition. An earlier instance of this raga usage was seen in Ilaiyaraaja's Kaalapaani - the female solo (Minnaaram Maanathu is the Malayalam version).

    Vikky, there's an excellent Shehnai piece with some great WCM arrangements in the sound track of Lajja (The wedding sequence of Mahima Choudhry).

    ReplyDelete
  13. Here's a link to the BGM I was referring to (first part of the video clip)

    http://movies.apunkachoice.com/titles/laj/lajja/mid_168/videos/moytid/OLGGILzp2FY/hindi-movie-lajja-part-9.html

    ReplyDelete
  14. In early eighties theere was a movie called Sadhanai, with Sivaji Ganaesan in lead. It was advertised that Raaja making whole movie in HCM, in vividh bharati.. It had good songs. Please can check that out too.

    ReplyDelete
  15. @ Neel:
    Thanks and Welcome here. Its a popular misconception that "Isayil Thodangudhamma" is Hamsanadham. Although the song has predominant Hamsanadham feel, presence of Dhaivatham in the melody and the interludes are beyond touch and go and establishing a character of that swara on its own. Hence I think its more appropriate to call it as "Saaranga Tharingini" which is Kalyani mninus Dha;

    Thanks for the Lajja link. The bgm is too good. Usage of Shehnai in such a fast paced Deep Chandi is heavnly indeed.

    @ Kuki:
    Thanks and Welcome here.
    Yes, songs of Saadhanai has a HCM feel to it because of the Tabla usage, but they are no more HCM than than Raaja's usual songs. Especially the song "athimara poovidhu" is a noteworthy Qawwali type of song. But in the absence of clapings as well as repetition of lines by the "party" they are just as much or lesser adoption of Qawwali by Raaja as I specified in the post 3 of this series; So the reference in the Aakasavani about highlighting the HCM in this movie could be more to do with marketing than its actual semblance to HCM.
    With Love
    Vicky

    ReplyDelete
  16. dear vicky,great analysis.two things here .wld be helpful if the songs can be tagged as it would go a long way in listening at our comfort!.the other clarification reqd is that you hve mentioned about the usage of keyboard santoor from 1988 onwards,i wld like to know how to differentiate between the original and the keyboard santoor.Last but not the least,reg the Qawali songs.just listen to chinna kuyil song from Poove Poochooda Vaa!.in the charanams.and identify the qawalis???.with warm regards.visu

    ReplyDelete